And it's not just rookies, but veterans have bad games throughout the year. Heck, before Eli Manning broke out of his funk this past weekend, the previous 3 games he threw 0 touchdowns and 4 interceptions, and he has good receivers and running backs around him. He had a 52 QB efficiency rating throughout those 3 games.

So you ask a question about something I didn't even mention and then you ask me to back up what I didn't mention?

Typical Rock.

That's probably why he gets his panties in a bunch when someone else mentions experts. In his mind, he is the only one...

There are some great back and forth discussions on these forums.

Unfortunately, there are also some that get hijacked by wannabe attorneys.

Ya, look at Drew Brees last night. "5" interceptions. "5"!!!!!!!!!!!
Everyone goes through their slumps. Tannehill is permitted to have his ups and downs. We as fans have to realize that, and stop living from the highs and lows from week to week.

Sorry, but Brees lost my Hall of Fame vote. I'm all for stripping his Superbowl ring as well.

However, if he throws 3 TDs and 350 yards the following week, he can have them back.

Who's talking about replacing him on every single bad play?

Oh that's right nobody.



Ya, like you're not a part of that. Dave was implicating everyone, not everyone but Rich. LMFAO.

Did you not make the comment: "Then every young QB is weak-minded because all the experts ever talk about is that you don't bench a young guy because you shatter his confidence."

So again, Tanny's "confidence" would be shattered if he had to sit a couple series?

Hahah ... what are we talking about here? EMO pop warner football?

I'm only speaking to the Tennessee game.

Who's talking about replacing him on every single bad play?

Oh that's right nobody.

I think that's Swerve replying to one of my posts where I said we should draft a QB every year, he might have took it that I want to replace RT which is incorrect. The way the salary cap is structured now, why not take a chance? It's better than drafting a bust TE in the 3rd. I would love to hit a gem and trade him seeing that QBs are a premium in this league.

basically everytime we lose a game the same 3 or 4 guys are on here instantly saying that Tanny is showing signs that he can't be our future quarterback and that he'll never be elite. You guys can't deny that you keep doing this all season. Then when we win it's back to high praise again. it's so ridiculous. "Must have Instant Gratification"

Like Dave and Phin have said, at times this year Eli and Brees have looked 5 times worse than Tannehill, and those guys are pro bowl QB's with Lombardi trophies.
Let the kid cut his teeth this season. No reason to panic unless he's still playing rookie ball in his 3rd season like Sanchez.

Who are these 3 to 4 guys who are instantly saying after every loss that Tanny is showing signs that he can't be our future qb and that he'll never be elite? Is this the same as the benching accusation you made earlier?

I don't see what you are saying going on at all.

They don't exist, just like the monster underneath his bed.

sure they don't. Bunch of wafflers.

But When we win a Super Bowl with Tanny those same 3 or 4 culprits will be at the front of the line celebrating and calling him the greatest QB savior ever.
Whatever is convenient for you.

But When we win a Super Bowl with Tanny those same 3 or 4 culprits will be at the front of the line celebrating and calling him the greatest QB savior ever.
Whatever is convenient for you

Answer the question, who are they? They exist in Swerve's World, Serve's World, it's party time,it's excellent...whoo whoo whoo.

He isn't worthy of the 8 pick...He doesnt deserve a chance at playing this year...He should be on the bench.

LMAO!! How did you make that? I need to get more "techy". Noce job Rock.

Are you saying that you are one of the ones swerve is talking about?


If so, in your defense, I think the first two thoughts are different than the specific accusation that there were 3 or 4 who are instantly saying that Tanny is showing signs that he can't be our future quarterback and that he'll never be elite and/or calling for his benching after every loss.

Nah. He's referring to anyone who had the nerve to think Tanny should've been the backup for his 1st year ..... under the guise that he has himself had an impeccable record for picking successful players.

Exactly. I personally thought sitting Tanny for at least the 1st part of the year would have been the better play considering his inexperience coming into the NFL. However, from his play this year sitting him was probably not needed, but we do not know the results had he sat for the 1st part either.

pretty pathetic waste of your time for someone who claims to be such a bigshot

you, Rock, Frustrated, Junkie....do we really have to pretend it isn't true


if you need evidence of your own comments here you go:

quote from PR:



he sees it too, and so do many other posters here. I'm not imagining it.

you, Rock, Frustrated, Junkie....do we really have to pretend it isn't true


if you need evidence of your own comments here you go:

Again, where does it say I want to replace him? Thanks proving it's Serve's World once agian.

Funny Swerve how you didn't pull all the positive things I have said about RT. Football is the biggest what have you done for me lately cliche and the above statements I stand by. It would be dumb to think that he is automatically the future just as it is dumb to replace him after one year. So you can keep posting your nonsense on the forums regarding me hating on RT. I believe this is the 4th or 5th thread I've posted regarding the issue, shame on me for wasting time on you when you clearly see things in your way in your world.

Do you really think that those quotes are evidence of this ?

So was this quote from around the time of the draft or after a game this year?

Do you really think that those quotes are evidence of this?

Quote:

the problem with most of the posters here bitching every time he makes a bad play to replace him with the journeyman backup.

and this

basically everytime we lose a game the same 3 or 4 guys are on here instantly saying that Tanny is showing signs that he can't be our future quarterback and that he'll never be elite.




Thank you and your right, it doesn't.

Draft. AFCMiamiEast made the opening part of the comment & I replied about not taking him at 8.

Yep, it is funny to look back at some of our pre-draft thoughts. I remember saying that Matt Ryan wasn't worth a first round pick even after I saw him play my Wolfpack his senior year. He would have turned out to be worth our overall #1 pick that year. Hindsight is definitely 20/20.

Yeap, some do not have the back bone to put their opinion out there, but play the 20/20 card.

Tanny has been able to take advantage of not having to learn an offense while also learning to play in the NFL. Miami turned out to be the perfect spot for him. I do not believe he would be doing as well on another team with a different offense. In saying that I do believe he has the skills to be a productive QB in the NFL.

Man, i wanted Ryan or even the other Long. Saw him play alot for BC

Who is he even quoting anyways?



You're talking to a guy who thinks Tanny already won a Super Bowl.

Nah. It was completely worth my time. Enjoyed every second of it.

He is still learning and that was evident today by missing Hartline twice. This TEAM is a few mistakes away from contending.