Think the last time he stayed healthy was is 1st yr? Maybe we used him to much makeing him about 80% of are offence? Tell me what you think

_________________

Did you already forget 2008? I don't know where you got your information, but Ronnie Brown is a loooooooooong way from 80% of the offense.

_________________

Ronnie is a big part of the offense when healthy, but 80% of the offense is unrealistic. Plus, this year Ricky Williams lead the team in TD's with 13, 11 rushing and 2 receiving. Ronnie finished with 8 TD's.

Brown and Williams did account for 65% of the touchdowns scored by the Dolphins last year.

As far as why Ronnie can't stay healthy, some of it is bad luck, but as much as you hate to say it, Ronnie has been susceptible to injuries. 1 full season since he was drafted makes you come to that conclusion.

2005-15, 2006-13, 2007-7, 2008-16, 2009-7 games.

_________________

acl injuries are a lot of times bad luck from taking a cut and such. wes welker last year is a prime example.

Ok your right not 80% of the O but seems like he did do more than his fare share and I need more than just 1 full season healthy from him but he is still a very good back

_________________

With Ronnie this offense, and this team, is playoff caliber. Without him, we are very mediocre.

He is our best player, and can do everything and has done everything for this football team. It really is unfortunate that he has not had a healthy career.

I think if he stays healthy and r other key players we could make a real good run at AFC east leader and who knows maybe take the whole AFC by storm the o-line looks good (qb) solid, (wr) needs little help Hartline and Bess were very good late pick ups so some help on the d-side and we could be good

_________________

We could plug in Spiller and be just fine.

Spiller does have speed and will run for days but dont think he is ready to take over for Ronnie just yet even with Ricky pulling some of the load

_________________

It's hard to have a good argument about just how good a RB is. However, I'll say this: Ronnie Brown is a complete back, and means the world to this offense, as we have seen whenever he has gotten hurt. CJ Spiller is a speedster who looks great on youtube videos because of the ammount of big plays he gets. However, give me the guy who gets 4-5 yards on every carry, rather than the guy who gets 1 or 2, and every once in a while breaks one.

It's fine to have a CJ Spiller in the rotation, but to make him your featured player on offense would be a mistake.

Give me a break. Spiller breaks one "every once in a while."? For once, do some research before spouting off.

_________________

Yes....every once in a while. Like once a game, sometimes none.

And again, this offense is about time of posession, driving down the field, wearing the defense out, moving the chains....If Spiller does not break one, he is killing drives. Sorry, but that's the truth.

"Like once a game." Haha...so a guy that breaks a TD "like once a game" just isn't worth it. Please, if you can get a guy that will score you a TD once a game, you take him. In case you didn't know, that's 16 TDs

_________________

Break one doesn't necassarily mean a TD. I mean like a 20 yarder, and yeah, sometimes the homerun.

And you don't make those types of guys featured backs, which is what I am argueing. Again, he is worth being used in a certain role, but not as THE guy.

There is no such thing as a feature back in the NFL anymore.

_________________

Phins, it would be certainly nice to see the Dolphins be more explosive. Grind it out drives are nice when you want to run the clock out, but putting points on the board is the main goal.

Plus, those long grind it out drives can lead to turnovers if you don't execute the entire drive.

Whether it be an explosive player like Spiller or Bryant, the big play needs to be more of a part of this offense.

_________________

Adrian Peterson, Chris Johnson, MJD, Michael Turner, Ryan Grant, Matt Forte (although maybe not anymore), Stephen Jackson, and Frank Gore are not featured backs??

But w.e. It's irrelevant.

Good job avoiding my point though.

You can have Stephen Jackson, the rest of those guys split carries.

You made no point.

_________________

I think you will see more big plays from everybody with a number 1 WR on the outside like Dez, including Ronnie and Ricky.

Spiller is a good player, and can contribute in a multitude of ways, but to me, he is no more than a role player. I don't think he is the next Chris Johnson, and do not think he is worth the 12th pick.

I agree that the offense needs to be more explosive, but that does not mean making a guy who averages 2-3 yards per carry, (taking out his big runs), you're featured player.

Chris Johnson splits carries? With who? Vince young?

Sorry, but Adrian Peterson is a featured back.

Frank Gore is/was the only guy who got any carries in San Fran.

MJD IS the Jaguar offense, and if he isn't getting a carry, it's because it's garbage time.

Who did Forte split carries with last year? Jay Cutler was their second leading rusher...

Michael Turner got nearly 400 carries in 2008, and would have gotten the same had it not been for injuries last year. That's not a feature back?

Did I forget someone??

But what the hell does this have to do with the original argument? You're avoiding my point...I'm done.

You made no point.
Guys getting injured are exactly my point. You can't be a feature back and expect to have a good offense. The Rams offense sucks. The Jaguars offense sucks. The Bears offense sucks. The 49ers offense sucks.

And AP split carries with Chester Taylor.

_________________

I'm pretty sure that AP had something like three times as many carries as taylor so that's not exactly splitting...
Not only do those teams offenses suck you have to remember that those Qb's running those offenses really sucked too so to say that the 'featured backs' are the problem is totally not fair.
Look at the Colts they run a 1 back system and they do alright or the packers?..I don't recall two backs there....it just boils down to being able to throw the football ,I think you can run a feature back if your strong in the passing game..

You made a good point Paydurt...I just wish Ronnie would stay healthy him and Rick plus Cobb coming back so u put anyone else back there and it will help

_________________

The Colts use three backs. Donald Brown, Joseph Addai and Mike Hart. Plus they throw the ball over 60% of the time anyway....successful offenses don't have feature backs, they have RB's by committee.

The Packers hardly run the ball...they were pretty inconsistent last year, but handoffs to Brandon Jackson and Ahman Green weren't uncommon throughout the year.

The days of Shaun Alexander, Jamal Lewis, Ricky Williams, Ladanian Tomlinson, Priest Holmes, or Ahman Green carrying your football are pretty much over.

AP is a tremendous back, yeah he's a feature back. So is MJD, Stephen Jackson....

but the point is, just because a guy isn't a "feature back" doesn't mean he's not worth a top pick.

_________________

I think Spiller can help us also with that speed if we can get him with a later pick or u think with the 12pick?

_________________

I think most if not all of Ronnie's injuries have been bad luck. He broke his thumb on a helmet one year and missed some games; hardly an endurance issue. His first year he missed some games towards the end of the season due to a hamstring injury; that might actually have been an endurance issue but not necessarily. The year he blew out his ACL was while trying to tackle the guy who intercepted one of Lemon's errant passes; not an endurance issue. Then last year he hurt his foot in a fluke deal.
Regardless of whether or not his injuries have been accidents or due to lack of endurance is a mute point, the fact remains that he has had only one healthy season while splitting carries.
The guy has great talent, but he doesn't have great luck when it comes to staying healthy. When on the field though, I believe he is a top 5 back in the NFL.

Man. You REALLY need to do some research before making judgments. If "he only breaks one once a game" is your best argument against taking Spiller, and your definition of breaking one is rushes of 20 yards or more, than Ronnie Brown sucks. Ronnie brown only has 12 CAREER runs of 20+ yards. That's one every 5 games.

I'm not trying to argue that we should take Spiller. I don't think we should. But your proclamations of genius football acumen are not supported by the facts, and it makes you look absolutely stupid. You are not an expert in football. Please stop pretending you are.

_________________
A good RB is nice, a good QB even better, but it's best to be able to stop someone first.

When did I ever say we shouldn't take Spiller because of the lack of big runs he has?

My argument is that while he does break off these long runs every once in a while, he is not an every down back, and when he does not break off these long runs, he is barely getting 2 or 3 yards a pop. Ronnie Brown is a horse that will get you 4-5 ypc. Give me that rather than a guy who will put you in 3rd and long situations consistently.

Again, I'm not saying Spiller is a bad player, or somebody that would not be good for this offense in a certain role. But as a featured back like iowa is suggesting? I don't think so. Chris Johnson's, Barry Sanderds...those guys are rare. CJ is not either of those 2 guys, and I think taking him at 12 with that sort of intention would be an horendous mistake.

Iowa, with all the needs that this team has, and with the amount of good talent at RB all over the draft, every year...you are really going to spend the 12 pick on a situational player?

As the great nonconformist thinker and philosopher of our time, Chad Ocho Cinco, would say....Child Please.

Personally, I think Brown and Spiller would compliment each other nicely. I am a big Ronnie Brown fan.. and I don't think he gets enough credit for what he means to this team. With that being said. We can't rest our season on whether or not this guy is going to be healthy. We need more firepower on our offense. IMO, we need a #1 WR. Spiller would be nice too.

_________________

i like spiller. he does remind me a lot of chris johnson with his flashiness. id love to see him in a dolphins uniform because ricky is getting old, and it has been proven thus far that ronnie cannot carry the load of carries throughout an entire season. he needs a back to split carries with, as he did in college, and spiller would definitely compliment him with a change of pace. that being said, if spiller and dez bryant were both available at 12, i would still take bryant.

So basically what your saying here is that only backs like Chris Johnson and Barry Sanders are worthy of being taken in the first round because they are (in your words) every down backs. Dude, as mentioned previously, your no football genius. I like you PR, but you need to be able to quit when your behind. You may be justified in your argument not to take Spiller because he is not a need, but your arguments to the affect of what an every down back is and all that, well they make you sound a bit foolish. If rb was a need, I wouldn't hesitate to spend it on Spiller, but its not a dire need for us, so I am not in favor of drafting him (although I won't cry if we do).

Lol. That's not what I was saying.

I used Barry Sanders and Chris Johnson as examples because those are who people (iowa) are comparing CJ Spiller too. And I'm saying that he is not. Finesse, pure speed RB's are rarely able to come into the NFL and be every down, featured players. See Reggie Bush.

That's all. Not saying that only if you are a Barry Sanders that you are worthy of the 12 pick. Just saying that you should be more than just a situational/role player.

More false facts.

_________________

You compare him to Johnson every chance you get.....


viewtopic.php?f=2&t=777&p=9018&hilit=Chris+Johnson#p9018


viewtopic.php?f=2&t=765&p=8979&hilit=Chris+Johnson#p8979



Sorry for all the false facts.

Ah, I love it when you prove me right.

Do you see any mention of Barry Sanders in there? The only "people" to compare him to Barry Sanders is you.

Just like you're the only one that makes Graham a SOLB and Hughes a WOLB.

_________________

You guys are silly. And off topic. Lol. Just my 2 cents.

I like Spiller a lot. It isn't fair to compare him to any legends until he shows what he can do at the next level. With that being said.. It would be nice to have him as compliment to Ronnie.. also in the event that Ronnie went down. We would still have a playmaker at the position.

_________________

PR, playmakers certainly are worth a first round pick. You don't have to be a grind it out powerhouse/workhorse back to be of value or worth taking in the first round. Spiller is first round talent (as far as you can tell at this point in time, which is what all teams have to do when they draft a player - - speculate) even if he isn't a CJ, AP, LT, or whoever else you want to compare him to. Is Reggie Bush (someone your comparing to) worth a first round pick? Well not the 2nd overall IMO, but I believe after what he did this year for the Saints, he would warrant a late first round pick.

He is...but not for a team like Miami. Not only are we not that type of a football team, but we have too many needs that can be filled with the emmense talent there is going to be at 12.

I just think it would be silly to draft a situational guy with very good OLB, possibly Dez, NT, and FS prospects available.