Im with you jammer regarding rosen. Im done with him.
Rosen has definitely had some bad moments. So has Baker Mayfield this year (leading the league in turnovers) when he hasn't had time to throw. Darnold looks terrible tonight. It takes time for a QB to develop. Sometimes, their mental game gets destroyed during the developmental phase, and that could very well be happening to Rosen. We'll see how mentally tough he is, but I'd love to see him play when he has an expectation of a clean pocket.
I maintain that there are a lot of QBs who could look like franchise QBs (i.e., good enough to be contributing factor on a Super Bowl team -- guys like Flacco and Matt Ryan count as borderline cases, Trent Dilfer does not) if they have reasonable talent around them. The truly elite like Brady, Manning, Rodgers, and Brees, who can elevate and carry the entire team, are quite rare. None of us know if any of those college guys are in that class.
For this reason, I'd rather have three first round picks than the overall first pick. I don't think it is worth giving up those picks to get into the top 5 (RG3 and Darnold come to mind). Conversely, I'd trade the #1 for a #5, a #20, and an unknown first pick the next year. (I'm making these up -- I don't' know exactly what the charts say.) We have so many holes to fill. We could put 20 first day picks to use in next year's draft if we had them.