_________________
Follow me on Facebook - Phinfever - Miami Dolphins Fan Site @BigDavePhinfever

Follow me on Twitter - David Blake@phinfever

Like it says, "IF" he can stay healthy...until then, he doesn't crack the top 5 running backs.

_________________

I understand that Ricky is old.... but I think he is a better back than some of those towards the bottom....

Maybe comparable to the unproven Shonn Green, although I can see where youth and promise can outweigh veteran experience.... Jonathan Stewart? well I think Ricky is more complete, and had a better year last year, and should do so again this year...... Beanie Wells? really? better than Ricky.... wow, just cause he was on a few top 10 college teams makes him a top 20 back, pfft... Forte? well i like him, but still... if it came down to it, I would chose Ricky over any of those 4...

As for Ronnie.... fair assessment of him. Ronnie is a one of a kind back, all the power you want, and enough burst. His top speed though is his ONLY downside as far as skills, many defenders have caught him from the back on the rare long runs in his career. But otherwise, pass catching, throwing ability, ability to lay the lumber, elusiveness, patience.... its all there. Injuries are his only major flaw..... Honestly, I wouldnt put him in the top 5 because of such..... Miami CANT rely on him, no matter how bad we all want to, it's been 4 years, and he's completed only 1 season! Id still fit him into the top 10 though.... with Ricky at 15

I once posted on these forums that when healthy Ronnie Brown is a top 10 back... I got bombarded by those who thought other wise.

I was about to post something saying good list...but then I saw Reggie Bush in his top 20.

Non the less, I like the fact that someone is finally giving him credit. He's a very good RB and a guy that can do every job for you on offense.

I will say though that DeAngelo Williams and MJD should have been ranked higher.

Ray Rice at 16 is a joke. That guy is a top 10 RB, and closer to top 5 than top 10.

as a runningback, Ray Rice is at 16. I can understand that, and as one of his biggest fans (and classmates) that is acceptable..... as an OVERALL FOOTBALL PLAYER... Id put him in a top 5 list........He does SOOO much outside of his RB position that it overshadows his RB game.... I mean think about it, his short yardage game is average at best. If your team is up by 4, with the ball and 4 minutes to play, your not gonna force feed Ray ray.... you'll give it to Mcgahee or McClain. Not saying that he isnt a dependable back, but he's got that Reggie Bush-ness but 10 times better.

The fact that Reggie is on this list is absurd. He is barely a RB to begin with

Ahhh another how good is Ronnie Brown really type of thread?

Like I've said in the past, I love the kid, but he can't stay on the field which does us no good.

Couldn't have said it better myself...

For kicks and giggles.

1. Chris Johnson- 4.2 speed, low to the ground, and can score every time he touches the football. 2k isn't just a name, it's a ridiculous amount of yards that few have seen.
2. Adrian Peterson- When he was drafted, I figured he'd be in Ronnie Brown company: Elite, but often injured. Instead, he's been elite/great, but fumble prone. Therefore, I knocked him to number 2.
3. Steven Jackson- He plays for a bad team, but in a league where it's vogue to have two RB's, he is still in the mold of 2005 or earlier and carries his team on the ground and the occasional check down pass.
4. MJD- Small back, big legs. He can get under a defender and carry them for seven more yards. Another feature back.
5. Michael Turner- I put all the feature backs at the top of the list, because that shows that they can be in the game for the whole game. Michael Turner was a two-back guy with LT, but his first season alone he blew up the league. An injury set him back, so number 5 seems fitting.
6. Frank Gore- A powerful back that can carry his team. Nothing flashy, just good old fashioned hard running...which is what Singletary enjoys, so he should have a great year.
7. DeAngelo Williams- He holds the NCAA record for most all-purpose yards. This guy can play.
8. Ray Rice- 2000 all-purpose yards. Is he top 5? Probably not, because he definitely benefits from playing in Cameron's system (that hurt dearly to say that).
9. Johnathon Stewart/Reshard Mendenhall- These are sort of the same back in my opinion. Then again, this whole thing is my opinion, so I'm being redundant.
10. Ronnie Brown- Great if healthy, non effective when not..obviously.
11. Ricky Williams- He's still got it. He'd be top 5 if he were the feature back, but if he were the feature back, he'd probably wear down. Either way, he's a starter on almost every other team.
12. Shonn Greene- Watched a lot of him in college. Does he have breakaway speed?-Asked the NFL scouts. Well, let the San Diego playoff game speak for that...however, not a lot of carries to be able to put him in the top 10 yet.
13. Matt Forte- He's a one cut back, with great hands. He should play well with Mike Martz.
14. Jamaal Charles- This kid is going to be a stud. I was amazed at his speed when he first got to KC, and Miami fans know first hand that when he gets the ball in his hands, he's a major threat. He's all over the field, catching, and most notably running wild in Denver.
15. Justin Forsett- Another runner that can catch. I enjoyed watching his powerful running at Cal, and he's proved be an excellent back in Seattle. He probably won't ever hit the 1000 yard mark rushing, but his all-purpose yardage will help whoever he plays to move the ball.
16. Pierre Thomas- Probably one of the most underrated players in the NFL. He plays second fiddle to Reggie Bush even though he sees a great bulk of the carries. He's a stud as a runner.
17. Marion Barber- Runs high, but still is able to put the lick on the defender. Felix Jones isn't on the list because he hasn't shown the tenacity of Barber, but Jones has the quick burst. Of the two backs, I like Barber, but they work great together.
18. Ryan Grant- A feature back on one of the top offensive teams in the league. He has to be in the top 20.
19. Darren McFadden- A bust? Who in Oakland isn't considered a bust? Get him out of there and you'll see one of the league's best backs, but because he's unmotivated (as is the entire organization) we hear about the bust. But if you've actually watched him run, you'd know that if he had at least one guy blocking hard for him, he could go the distance on every carry.
20. Darren Sproles- Can catch, can run, and return punts and kicks. He constantly gets knocked for his lack of size, but his play has never shown he can't take a beating. 200+ rushing yards and 300 all-purpose yards against Indy in the playoffs doesn't happen to just any back (Lamar Smith?). Maybe, it's just the Colts D, eh?

Almost, but not quite:
Ryan Matthews- He's a rookie, what can I say?

Felix Jones- Most people he's in the top 15, but I honestly haven't seen him play enough...he seems to me to be a guy that will always play well with others and never be able to take the full load, unlike his former teammate McFadden.

Thomas Jones- 1400 yards last year, and he didn't seem to lose a step. However, I expect his age and the wear and tear to catch up with him at some point this season. But that's what Jamaal Charles is for.

Cedric Benson- Until he's able to put back to back good seasons together, I'll always consider this guy a bust. His arrest in Texas recently doesn't bode well for him either.

Jerome Harrison- A one-hit wonder?

Clinton Portis- All this guy has done is post 1500 or more all-purpose yards for 6 of his 8 seasons. However, the injury last year limited him to just 8 games and 400 yards, and the consistent 325+ carry seasons he's had leads me to believe his prime is in the rear view mirror.

_________________

I can't argue with most of that list, iowa...but how can you put Stewart and Mendenhall over Ronnie?

Also, Greene had a good post season...Pierre Thomas has been stellar all around for the Saints for multiple seasons now. I would have put him over Greene.

But like I said, I can't argue with most of it.

I'm still not very high on DeAngelo Williams... something about him just screams inconsistent... the numbers disagree but I think he'll end up falling off the face of the earth.

I'd also put Jamaal Charles and Ryan Grant higher... also, where the heck is Joey Addai? May not seem like a great back under the spot light of Peyton Manning, but check his numbers man.

LeSean McCoy should be in consideration as well.

3.8 YPC and 3.5 YPC are pretty sad for an NFL running back. He's pretty quick on turf, but there's a reason the Colts drafted Donald Brown.

As for LeSean McCoy, I guess nothing he's done has impressed me. About 900 yards in all-purpose yardage. Maybe if he performs well this coming season, but one year and nothing flashy isn't enough to constitute a top 20 player.

_________________

Thomas over Greene makes sense. As for Stewart and Mendenhall over Brown? They both had stellar second seasons in the league last year, Stewart had a YPC of 5.1...a feat that Brown only mustered once, and that was only through 8 games. Mendenhall also hit a 4.6 YPC..which again is a feat Brown only beat in 2007. And Mendenhall did it with a completely atrocious offensive line.

Is Brown an excellent back? Yes, but he's got to stay healthy and be consistent. Stewart and Mendenhall have the consistency to work on, but in just the one year they did better than Brown has done in his 5 years.

_________________

It amazes me that Stewart has been able to amass such numbers in a secondary role. Pretty impressive.

I think if you're going to put the likes of Forsett and McFadden on there you should probably include Addai and McCoy... but again its just a small change there, none of them are all-stars at this point.

If Ronnie Brown was to DeAngelo Williams what Stewart is to him, or even what Ricky is to RB, he would also be getting 5.1 ypc.

Mendenhall is a good runner, but where is the versatility? Whenever I watch him play he just does not have it receiving wise, and is not a very good blocker-picker-upper (something I believe Ronnie is best in the league at for a tailback). He's a one trick pony. Ronnie can do many more jobs for your offense than Mendenhall. He also had a much better passing game to open things up for him.

But if we're talking ypc, shouldn't Ricky also be higher than Ronnie?

You lost me on that first sentence. Mendenhall essentially had his first year last year, so his pass assignments should improve...as for receiving, that's unfair considering he isn't asked to do that the majority of the time. The Steelers play action to the back and go to the receivers/tight ends.

As far as the RIcky/Ronnie...they are right by each other. Don't be nit picky.

_________________

What I meant was that if Ronnie was spelling DeAngelo Williams like Jonathon Stewart does, Ronnie would too have a 5.1 ypc. Ronnie is the feature back here, though, and bruises defenses opening things up for Ricky. If Ronnie was the change of pace he would be getting more production per pop.

See Brandon Jacobs.

Very solid list. I need to see how Shonn Greene for a full season before I put him that high. I think Jamaal Charles could be a special back.

Ronnie Brown has the potential to be a top 5 back easily, as he can do it all. But, and you hate to continue to say it, but it is very true. He has to stay healthy and be on the field, and there no getting around that.

Agree very much with Ricky being in the top 15. Ricky is still big, fast and explosive and has very good hands in the passing game as well. The only drawback with Ricky at this point is his age.

_________________

I wouldn't say that Ricky has very good hands in the passing game, SC. Ricky dropped a lot of passes towards the end of last season, and one resulting in a pick against Houston.

He doesn't have near the hands that Brown does.

_________________

He may not be Marshall Faulk or even Ronnie Brown out the backfield, but Ricky has solid hands out of the backfield. He certainly not a liability.

_________________